Platform guides· Thomas Cuccittini 6 min read
Etsy vs Shopify vs WooCommerce vs eBay: Which Should You Start On?
Five questions that decide where to start selling online, the published fees for each platform on the same $40 order, and why you can start on one and copy listings to another later.

Etsy vs Shopify is rarely a question about fees alone, and the same goes for WooCommerce and eBay. Each platform answers a different question: where do your buyers look, what are you selling, and how much of the store do you want to run yourself. This guide gives five questions that decide where to start, sets the published fees side by side on one $40 order, and shows how to start on one platform and copy listings to another later.
Start on one store, copy to another when you are ready
How Cashowa works for sellersFive questions that decide where to start
1. Where will your buyers look? On Etsy and eBay, shoppers search the marketplace itself, so a listing can be found by people who have never heard of you. On Shopify or WooCommerce, visitors arrive because of what you do to bring them: search, ads, social media, email and links. Neither is better in general. It depends on whether you would rather compete for attention inside a marketplace or build your own audience.
2. What are you selling? Etsy's help page on what you can sell says every listing has to be made, designed, handpicked or sourced by you, so Etsy fits handmade goods, original designs, vintage and craft supplies. eBay's fees page sets rates by category, so look up yours. On your own store, the products are yours to choose, within the rules of your payment provider and the law.
3. How much do you want to run yourself? On a marketplace you list products and follow its policies. Shopify's plans run the store software for you, and you set up the store with its checklist (how to start a Shopify store). With WooCommerce you choose a host and keep WordPress, the plugin and the theme up to date (how to start a WooCommerce store).
4. How much setup are you ready for? Etsy asks for identity verification, a bank account, a billing card and a first listing before you open (how to start an Etsy shop). eBay asks you to register, verify and choose an account type (how to sell on eBay). Shopify's checklist has dozens of steps, and WooCommerce starts with choosing a host.
5. What do you pay as you grow? The next section answers that for one order.
Etsy vs Shopify vs the rest: what each charges on a $40 order
The table uses the published US rates, read on November 16, 2026 from Etsy's fee help page, eBay's selling fees page, Shopify's pricing page and WooCommerce's WooPayments page. The order is a $35 item with $5 shipping, paid by card, with no sales tax.
| What you pay to have a shop | Fees on the $40 order | |
|---|---|---|
| Etsy | $0.20 per listing, renewed every four months; a one-time set-up fee where it applies | $4.05: 6.5% transaction fee ($2.60) and 3% + $0.25 payment processing ($1.45). An Offsite Ads sale adds $6.00 (15%) |
| eBay | First 250 listings a month free, then $0.35 each | $5.84: 13.6% final value fee ($5.44) and a $0.40 per-order fee |
| Shopify (Basic) | $27 a month on monthly billing, $19 with yearly billing | $1.46 with Shopify Payments (2.9% + $0.30) |
| WooCommerce | Hosting, a domain and any paid extensions, which vary by provider | $1.46 with WooPayments (2.90% + $0.30) |
Etsy's figure leaves out the listing fee, and eBay's assumes a category at the standard rate. Shopify's and WooCommerce's cover the card fee only. The hosting a WooCommerce store needs is not in the table because it depends on the host you pick.
Fees alone make an interesting sum. Against Etsy's per-order fees on these orders, Shopify Basic saves $2.59 an order ($4.05 minus $1.46), so its $27 monthly plan costs less than Etsy's per-order fees from about ten orders a month ($27 divided by $2.59). Against eBay it saves $4.38 an order, so the crossover is about six orders a month. That sum leaves out the biggest difference between a marketplace and your own store, which is who finds the shop. For the full Etsy stack, see Etsy fees: what Etsy actually takes from a $30 sale, and for a three-way comparison see Etsy vs eBay vs Amazon.
You can start on one platform and add another later
Choosing is less final than it looks. You can start where your buyers already are and add a second place once the first works. What makes that practical is not retyping each listing. A listing's title, description, tags, photos and SKU can move across, and you adjust what each platform asks for separately: the category, the shipping and the policies.
Mistakes worth checking for
- Comparing one platform's headline fee with another's total. Etsy quotes 6.5% and eBay 13.6%, but each is part of a different stack.
- Counting only the plan price. A Shopify plan or a WooCommerce host is a fixed cost, and the card fee comes on top of it.
- Forgetting who brings the shoppers. On your own store, that is you.
- Choosing by one month of fees. The right answer can change as your order count changes.
- Copying a title that breaks the next platform's limit. Etsy allows 140 characters and eBay 80.
Where Cashowa fits
Cashowa connects to all four: Etsy and eBay through their own sign-in and approval screens, Shopify from the Shopify App Store, and WooCommerce through your own store's approval page. Start on one, and when you are ready to add another, Cashowa copies a listing from one of your stores to another. The copy carries the title, description, tags, photos, SKU and quantity, and the price when both stores sell in the same currency, and the card lists what you still set on the other platform, such as variations, shipping and categories. You review the copy and approve it. It starts as a draft on Etsy, Shopify and WooCommerce, and on eBay approving lists it. Which store holds the stock count is yours to decide, so pick one and keep it there. How Cashowa works for sellers says what it reads and keeps.
Frequently asked questions
Is Etsy or Shopify better for a beginner?
It depends on what you sell and how you plan to find buyers. Etsy takes items you made, designed, handpicked or sourced, and shoppers search Etsy itself. Shopify gives you your own store and your own checkout, and you bring the visitors. The five questions above are a way to decide.
Which platform has the lowest fees?
On the $40 example, Shopify Basic and WooCommerce with WooPayments have the lowest per-order card fee, $1.46, but Shopify adds a monthly plan and WooCommerce adds hosting. Etsy's organic per-order fees are $4.05 plus the listing fee, and eBay's are $5.84. The figures change, so check each platform's page.
Can I sell on Etsy and Shopify at the same time?
Yes. Cashowa can copy a listing from one of your stores to another, and each platform's own rules still apply to the listing you create there.
Can I move my Etsy listings to Shopify?
You can copy them. Cashowa carries over the title, description, tags, photos, SKU and quantity, and the price when both stores sell in the same currency. You then set what Shopify asks for separately, and the copy starts as a Shopify draft product for you to publish.
The term 'Etsy' is a trademark of Etsy, Inc. This Application uses Etsy's API, but is not endorsed or certified by Etsy. eBay, Amazon, Shopify and WooCommerce are trademarks of their respective owners. Cashowa is independent and is not endorsed or certified by any of them.